Your Kid’s Not Going Pro

A Youth Sports Blog

'Friday Night Lights' book star grows up to be unlikely hometown arrest

with 6 comments

friday-night-lights_l1Brian Chavez, the genius/tight end of the Permian Panthers in the book Friday Night Lights, was the last person in the book you expected to make his adult life in Odessa, Texas, and then get arrested there. And yet, both have happened.

A few hours after Permian lost 26-7 to crosstown rival at Ratliff Stadium, the often sold-out 19,000-seat field featured in Friday Night Lights, Chavez (No. 85, front and center on the book cover) was among four people arrested on burglary charges in Odessa. According to local news reports, Chavez and several others broke into a home and attacked an unspecified number of men inside it, with one man saying he needed stitches after he was beaten with statuettes found inside the home. Chavez was arrested at 1 a.m. Sat., Oct. 3.

In the book and movie Friday Night Lights, Brian Chavez is portrayed as the genius jock, one of the few players who seemed to have academic and life ambitions beyond the rough oil town of Odessa, Texas, after his graduation from Permian High School. Funny thing is, Chavez, who left West Texas for Harvard University, is among the members of that 1988 Permian team, chronicled by H.G. “Buzz” Bissinger, to live in Odessa, where he practices criminal defense law.

Chavez told the Odessa American in August that after graduating from law school at Texas Tech, he wanted to come back to his hometown to work in his father and brother’s law firm to get a little bit of experience before moving on. However, he stuck around because the law practice became so successful, with four offices in West Texas and the Rio Grande Valley, and because he liked living close to his extended family.

It sounds plausible, although you don’t hear a lot of Harvard graduates who decide to go to law school at Texas Tech and then go home to their small town to represent drunk drivers and sex offenders. When ESPN came to Odessa for a 20-year reunion of the Friday Night Lights Permian team, Chavez talked again of liking being back in his hometown, and that “other than gaining some weight and losing a little hair, I’m probably the same person I was back then.”

So why was Chavez arrested for a violent burglary? Details are still very sketchy as to motive. But more than motive, why would someone who seemed to have a happy, successful life ever even conceive of participating in something like this? (Assuming of course that he did.) There is bound to be an interesting story behind this, one that may well shock those who thought they knew Brian Chavez (the possibly shocked would include Bissinger, who told ESPN last year he is still close to him.)

And what about those arrested with Chavez? One was his brother, Jake. He is a lawyer, too, though not the brother listed on the Web site of the Chavez Law Firm with Brian Chavez — that is Adrian. Another was Rosemary Soto of Odessa. A Rosemary Soto of Odessa was quoted in local media talking about her brother, Steven, in June being shot to death with another man in what authorities called a drug-related hit. It’s not clear whether the arrested person is the same Rosemary Soto.

Finally, another person arrested has connection to Friday Night Lights. Stanley Wilkins was a teammate of Chavez on that 1988 Permian team, although he was a minor character in the book. ESPN, in its 20-year reunion story, described Wilkins as missing “those Friday Night Lights more than anything in the world. He often attends Permian games with his former teammates Brian Chavez to relive past glories.” Wilkins also is a football coach and physical education teacher at Bowie Junior High School in Odessa. Word late Sunday night from Odessa police, as reported by KOSA-TV, is witnesses saying that 10 to 12 people showed up at the home that was the site of the alleged break-in, and that the fight inside followed “several hours of verbal harassment by the suspects outside their home.”

Chavez has not commented on the case. I have sent him an email to try to get in contact with him. I also have sent an email to Bissinger, just to see what his thought are because of his professed closeness with the Chavez family, and because Chavez was the one player who for years vouched for the book’s accuracy when the rest of Odessa was ready to tar and feather him.


6 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Because I spend so much of my life reporting and writing about miscarriages of justice (see my T/S blog “In Justice”), it’s difficult to set aside my suspicion when I hear about unlikely arrests. I wonder how many red flags I’d find if I studied the circumstances closely. Needless to say, the Friday Night Lights hero might be the actual perpetrator, but nobody should accept police and prosecutor accounts without asking lots of questions. I hope you’ll provide your T/S readers with more information eventually.

    Steve Weinberg

    October 4, 2009 at 11:18 pm

  2. I will as I get it, and I certainly appreciate your point.

    Bob Cook

    October 4, 2009 at 11:52 pm

  3. Something I just found that has nothing to do with this case, necessarily, but may be of interest to anyone seeing cryptic references online to the father of Brian Chavez being involved in past shady dealings:

    From the Odessa American, May 28, 2009:

    About eight years after being released from federal prison, former local attorney Jose Antonio “Tony” Chavez was told Thursday that he can once again try to earn a license to practice law in Texas.

    Before returning to legal practice with his two sons (NOTE: this is why I changed the reference to Adrian in the main story), however, Chavez will have to take and pass the Texas bar exam to regain his license.

    During the hearing, at least 20 witnesses were present to testify to Odessa District Court Judge John Smith about Chavez’s commendable personal character and professional legal aptitude, especially since his 16-month stint in prison for being an “accessory after the fact” to a drug ring that stretched from Odessa down to Chihuahua, Mexico.

    Bob Cook

    October 5, 2009 at 1:53 pm

  4. Geez, I hate to keep commenting on my own post, but here’s an interesting tidbit I found. The most troubled player in the book, Boobie Miles, has on occasion retained his old teammate Brian Chavez as his defense attorney.

    Bob Cook

    October 5, 2009 at 5:59 pm

  5. […] has a strange story, about the arrest for home invasion of Brian Chavez, the whiz-kid tight end from Buzz Bissinger’s “Friday Night Lights.” In the book, […]

  6. Did you ever figure this out? I have tried to from time to time, being obsessed with FNL the book… and of their lives in the post glory days…. I can’t figure it out, even after they plead! I am glad that Chavo only had his license suspended and was not disbarred. I have no personal relationship with him, but I love the boys from the FNL book:)


    December 14, 2014 at 8:55 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: